The Attorney At Large’s Guide to Urban Manners, Part I: Hats
Posted on May 25th, 2011
Look, I realize not everybody read a 1960s edition of Emily Post for fun (the rules on smoking after supper are quite amusing). Not everybody married a man who was trained in hat etiquette by a hat model (his mother). Not everybody spent spare weekends in college explaining to ushers which arm to offer to the ladies and how to walk like a gentleman. What can I say? I’m a lucky girl.
But even in laid-back, laissez-faire Portland, I am horrified by the lack of civility around me. Today, when an old man let a door slam on P and me (in the driving rain!), I’d had enough. I decided it’s time for a new series: the Attorney At Large’s Guide to Urban Manners.
Disclaimer: I’m not perfect. No, really. I spend too much time at cafes and restaurants with paper napkins, and as a result my table manners could use a good once-over, or maybe even two. My posture gets worse with each year I spend hunched over a laptop screen. I’m easily distracted by shiny objects. But you know what else I’m not? I’m not rude, even when I’m being snarky or making pointed remarks to rude people.
I’m starting with hats, mostly because I like hats, but also because I want to create a public record for the media to find when I go on a mad hat-tipping spree through the restaurants and shops of Portland. Also, don’t expect gender equality: until the ERA passes, I expect men to remove their hats indoors. Really, how hard is it? Apparently, quite. So I’ll say it again, in bold:
Men remove their hats indoors. That’s the bright-line rule. If you follow that, you’ll be safe. But if you want to get all technical and lawyerly, there are nuances. If you are indoors in a public place (like a museum or a train station or a hotel lobby), you don’t have to remove your hat. If you are passing through a place, you don’t have to remove your hat. Around here, we have had a spirited debate about what to do in a restaurant when waiting for takeout. Technically, you wouldn’t have to remove your hat. Personally, I think it’s tacky to stand around with a hat on when there are diners seated and eating nearby.
If you put your butt on a chair in a public place? The hat comes off. If you meet a lady on the street and stand and talk to her? The hat comes off.
Women do not have to remove their hats indoors. (I know, it’s not fair. Cry me a river.) That said, I will take off a soggy, wet hat (or a really “outdoorsy” hat) rather than drip all over food or merchandise or children.
Ball caps are not hats. They’re sporting apparel, and unless you’re running, playing a sport, or watching a sport, you shouldn’t wear one, and that goes for men and women. It’s like wearing a jock strap on your head. Also, the only person allowed to wear a ball cap backward is the catcher. (H/T to Isaac.)
I recently saw a professional, put-together woman walking with a man with a ball cap on backwards and all I could think was, “Why is this woman with this idiot?” Did he forget which side of his head is front?
Oh, these are antiquated, you think. No one follows these anymore. Who the hell are you, anyway? I say: (1) maybe, (2) yes, some men do, and (3) good, bad, I’m the redhead with the gun. But here is the thing: being polite never goes out of style. Ever.

What is you opinion on wearing a baseball hat on a weekend morning grocery run for both men and women? Just curious.
I hate backward baseball caps, but I especially hate ones that are turned just a tiny bit to the side.
I don’t see hats very often around here (MN). Not syre why we’re not a hat culture.
Technically, I hate the idea, but I’ve used a cap to hide bedhead on a store run, too. It’s been years, though. Now I have soft caps made out of recycled cashmere sweaters (locally made in Portland – how Portlandia is that?) that I’ll use under those circumstances.
Thanks for the hat tip, though as I’m a traditionalist it’s really I who should be tipping my hat to you.
I’ve heard a spirited debate about men’s hats in elevators: the traditionalists say “take them off, because an elevator cab is as “indoors” as a room can be; the practicalists say “leave them on if the elevator is crowded, because you take up less room with your hat atop your head than in front of you.” I mostly take mine off, not so much because of any special elevator rule as because I’ve already taken it off when I entered the building that houses the elevator.
I can’t remember the last time I have seen anyone, man or woman, wear a hat – indoors or out. The one exception is that I live across the street from a huge AME church. The ladies wear hats to church. But otherwise, I never see it. Plus, I think backwards baseball hats are cool. Perhaps that makes me uncouth, but I don’t care. I live in Boston. I have to chose my battles. There is no fighting Red Sox caps, backwards or forwards here. I might as well embrace it.
+ 1 BILLION points for the Army of Darkness reference!!
Oh, this was delightful. I can’t wait for the next installment. Even if Patrick and I take turns wearing his Canucks hat. Sorry. We don’t wear it indoors!
I know, I’m fighting a losing battle with the ballcaps. Sigh.
@Isaac: The elevator etiquette is particularly interesting. OK to keep on unless a lady enters the elevator! Practically speaking, when we leave the house (and it’s usually just the three of us in the elevator), we put hats on leaving the house and leave them on in the elevator and the lobby. (Also really crazy and confusing: Navy hat/saluting etiquette, which M also knows. I can’t keep it straight.)
@GoogieBaba: So envious of the proximity to the AME church. So many fun hats! Also, I’m surprised you don’t see more hats! I would think with your climate, it would be a practical matter. (I would probably be chicken to go on a cap-tipping spree in Boston.)
@Mglickman: and +1 Billion to you for getting it!
@Ann: Why am I not surprised Patrick has a Canucks hat?!
I love it… love it. But it’s funny that someone mentioned Boston because the first thought was “But Ben Affleck looks so damn adorable in the backwards baseball cap paparazzi shots.” I’m not defending my love of Ben, just confessing that it was my thought. I was thinking too though that I don’t know an adult who wears hats, except cold weather toques. Maybe our children’s generation will be more into hats since most of them wear them all summer. P has the most adorable straw fedora I got him and he’s been wearing it everywhere (outside!) – it is adorable. I would love for men to start wearing hats again a la Don Draper.
THANK YOU! I f*ing hate baseball caps so much that I wish I could wipe them from the face of the earth. If you aren’t playing baseball, DON’T wear one. Because they are fugly, and no matter who you are, no, you do NOT look good in it.
Hate. Them.
In my neighborhood is a kick a** independently owned hat store. You need to come visit.
A question. First. I agree completely with you and thank you for talking about this! Can you also discuss the disgustingness of gum smacking. If you shouldn’t chew your food with your mouth open, then the same applies to gum, AND I shouldn’t have to hear your gum. It should be a silent activity. The end.
My question- visors?? I wear a visor when I go running. Often, in my rush to get other things to happen in my day, I’ll proceed with my stinky-visored-self to the grocery store or post office or wherever today’s errands take me. Is this a faux pas??
I think that if you’re appending a grocery run onto exercise, it’s excusable. Also: having a kid under 6 months gives you a pass on ALL these rules!